Aetna fraud suit against Radiology Partners dismissed in Florida
The Middle District of Florida dismissed Aetna’s lawsuit over No Surprises Act IDR awards involving Radiology Partners and Mori, Bean and Brooks.
A federal judge in Florida has dismissed Aetna’s fraud lawsuit against Radiology Partners and Mori, Bean and Brooks. The case centered on No Surprises Act independent dispute resolution awards involving radiology claims in Florida.
The lawsuit was filed by Aetna Health, Aetna Life Insurance, and Aetna Health Insurance in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida. Radiology Partners and Mori, Bean and Brooks were named as defendants.
Aetna alleged that after Radiology Partners acquired Mori, Bean and Brooks, claims from other Florida radiology practices were routed through Mori, Bean and Brooks to obtain higher reimbursements. The court noted that Aetna terminated Mori, Bean and Brooks’ in-network contract after claim submissions increased.
After the contract termination, Aetna alleged that other Radiology Partners practices continued submitting claims through Mori, Bean and Brooks as out-of-network claims. The complaint alleged that this led to higher payment through the No Surprises Act IDR process.
Aetna sought to vacate IDR awards, recover fees tied to arbitration participation, and limit disputed claims not yet filed through IDR. Radiology Partners and Mori, Bean and Brooks moved to dismiss the amended complaint.
Judge Brian J. Davis said Aetna had sufficiently alleged that claims were fraudulently submitted as out-of-network claims. But the court found that Aetna did not meet the standard needed to challenge the IDR awards after arbitration.
“While a close call,” the court said Aetna had not established enough basis to excuse its failure to raise the issue during the IDR process.
The court found that Aetna knew about the alleged billing practice before or during arbitration. It said Aetna’s knowledge was fatal to its position because the alleged fraud was discoverable through due diligence.
Davis also rejected Aetna’s remaining claims. The order said allowing Aetna to recover the difference between IDR awards and what it otherwise would have paid would have the same effect as discarding the administrative process established by Congress.
The amended complaint was dismissed with prejudice because amendment would be futile, according to the order. The court directed the clerk to close the case.
Aetna has appealed. A notice of appeal was filed May 6 and docketed May 8 in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, according to Justia.
Company:Radiology Partners
Radiology Partners coverage
About the author
RadiologySignal.com writersEditorial Team
Radiology Signal Staff covers developments across medical imaging, radiology AI, imaging informatics, clinical research, and radiology business. The team monitors primary sources, peer-reviewed studies, company announcements, society updates, and healthcare industry news to deliver concise reporting for imaging professionals.
More from this section
Richmond radiology practice reports 266K-record breach
Radiology Associates of Richmond said an unauthorized actor accessed its network in July 2025, with notification letters sent to affected individuals starting May 21, 2026.
Lumexa Imaging reports vendor-related data incident
A vendor incident may have exposed patient identifiers, insurance information, diagnoses, visit dates, and other radiology-related health information tied to Lumexa-affiliated practices.
MOC-linked radiation oncology care associated with lower Medicare costs
A retrospective Medicare Part B analysis found that radiation oncologists voluntarily participating in ABR maintenance of certification used more advanced techniques and had 10.31% lower Medicare costs per treatment course.
Senators reintroduce MARCA radiologist assistant reimbursement bill
The Medicare Access to Radiology Care Act would allow radiologists to submit Medicare claims for nondiagnostic services performed by radiologist assistants under direct supervision in hospital and office settings.
House committee advances Medicare physician payment reform bill
The Provider Reimbursement Stability Act of 2026 would limit annual Medicare conversion-factor changes to ±2.5% and raise the budget-neutrality threshold.
International Focused Ultrasound Society launches
The new society will focus on clinical adoption, training, credentialing, coding, billing, clinical guidelines, patient advocacy, and industry partnerships.
AMA warns patients not to rely on AI for diagnosis
AMA released patient-facing prompts and cautions for health AI chatbot use, saying AI should supplement, not replace, physician expertise.
RANT projects $51M in No Surprises Act admin costs
Radiology Associates of North Texas said current batching rules and unpaid IDR awards could create more than $51M in avoidable administrative costs.
ACR issues guidance for breast biopsy needle shortage
The guidance offers triage, conservation, inventory, case-prioritization, and patient-communication strategies for practices affected by the stereotactic breast biopsy needle shortage.
USC names Joshua Hirsch chair of radiology
Hirsch joins Keck School of Medicine of USC from Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, bringing experience in neurointervention, health policy, quality, and clinical operations.
Haridopolos to assume surgeon general duties temporarily
Stephanie Haridopolos will assume some surgeon general duties while radiologist Nicole Saphier awaits Senate confirmation.
Radiology groups back Medicare pay-stability bill
ACR, SIR, ASNR, and other physician groups urged Congress to pass H.R. 8163, the Provider Reimbursement Stability Act.